Non-surgical complications in oncological colorectal surgery: a comparison between open and laparoscopic techniques

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Most of the studies on laparoscopic surgery in the treatment of colorectal cancer analyzed the oncological or surgical outcome. It remains to be clarified, if laparoscopic surgery leads to a significant reduction in the incidence of systemic complications in the postoperative period.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: We undertook a quantitative and qualitative assessment of non-surgical complications arising in our patients during the postoperative stay ,in relation to laparoscopic surgery compared to open surgery for colorectal cancer. In the study, 426 patients were recruited. The interventions were performed by an open technique for 225 patients, in VL for 145 patients and 56 patients were subjected to intraoperative conversion.

RESULTS: The correlation between surgical technique and onset cardiac complications showed a higher rate of onset of these in open (11.7%) than the VL technique (5.5%). Same result for pulmonary complications (open 13.2%, VL 3.4%) and renal (open 5.7%, VL 1.4%). Average age of patients treated with open surgery 75 years, average operating time duration 169 minutes. Average age patients treated in VL 69 years, average operating time duration 175 minutes.A possible benefit of videolaparoscopic rectal surgery on non-surgical complications has also been investigated, but a significant conclusion has not been reached due to the small number of adverse events found in the reference sample.

The evaluation of the duration of the operating session in relation to non-surgical complications showed an increase in the occurrence of pulmonary, renal and systemic adverse events. There was also a significantly greater risk of pulmonary complications in male patients (M 12.7%, F 6.8%). Finally, by stratifying patients by age, a significant positive correlation emerged in the onset of pulmonary complications in the subgroup of patients aged ≥ 70 years, operated with open technique (open 14.6%, vl 3.8).

CONCLUSIONS: The data analysed shows a reduction of pulmonary and renal cardiac adverse events after laparoscopic oncological surgery, it has not come to a conclusion for rectal cancer. There is also an increase in adverse events related to the duration of the operating session, the male sex and the age ≥ 70 years, thus enhancing the hypothesis that elderly patients are actually the population who can ultimately benefit more of minimally invasive surgical techniques.