Clinical Value of Cervical Mediastinoscopy in the Staging of Bronchial Carcinoma

Abstract

Whether mediastinoscopy is indicated in the preoperative staging of bronchogenic carcinoma is still a controversial issue.

It may be performed routinely (to exclude locally inoperable patients from surgery), selectively, or it may be regarde as superfluous (in centers which prefer an extended lymphoadenectomy at the time of thoracotomy). We regard mediastinoscopy as indicated for the following purposes: 1) staging of NSCLC and SCLC; 2) diagnostic (mediastinal masses or lung tumors without previous histology); 3) restaging after primary chemotherapy; 4) assessment of prognosis in patients with borderline operability. The indication for 224 mediastinoscopies performed at our institution in the period from September 1991 through March 1999 was mainly for staging (59.2%) or diagnostic (30.6%). Eight (5.4%) patients underwent mediastinoscopy for the assessment of operability, and 7 (4.8%) after primary chemotherapy for the restaging of loco-regionally advanced lung cancer. Sensivity and specificity rates were 87% and 100%, respectively, with an accuracy of 93% for the mediastinoscopy performed for the staging of lung cancer at all stages. If we consider the N2 tumors (42 cases) alone, the sensivity was 76.7% and the specificity 100%, with an accuracy of 83.3%. Overall positive and negative predictive value resulted 100% and 87%, respectively, according to the data reported in literature. Our data confirm the role of mediastinoscopy as the gold standard for regional staging of lung cancer.